The Conroy - Modern Supper Club

BF Boss

4 months ago

Fellow restaurants in Milwaukee, watch out! The Conroy delivers an exceptional dining experience from start to finish. The food is beautifully prepared, full of flavor, and thoughtfully presented, with every dish showcasing high-quality ingredients and attention to detail. The drink selection is equally impressive, offering expertly crafted cocktails and a well-curated wine list that perfectly complements the menu. What truly sets Conroy apart, however, is the outstanding service. The staff are attentive, knowledgeable, and genuinely welcoming, creating an atmosphere that feels both refined and comfortable. Every aspect of the experience feels carefully considered, making Conroy a standout destination for anyone looking for memorable food, drinks, and hospitality. Thank you to our server Kayla and the bartender whose name I didn’t get but he made DELIGHTFUL drinks! Wow, can’t wait to come back.

Brittney B.

5 months ago

Went to The Conroy for my birthday celebration, and I can honestly say the atmosphere was beautiful—dim lighting, but still bright enough to see each other comfortably. They also had live jazz music, which really set the tone and elevated the entire ambience of the space. The food was amazing, and the drinks were just as good. The only downside was parking. They do offer valet, but be aware that they don’t have their own dedicated valet service and share it with the business across the street. Because of that, we waited an additional 15–20 minutes for valet before we could even enter the restaurant. Once we were seated, we waited another 25–30 minutes for a server to come to our table. We eventually got the attention of a staff member who walked by—his name was Ethan, and he works at the bar with Rebecca, who is also amazing. Ethan ended up being our server for the night, and he was absolutely wonderful. Would I recommend this restaurant? Yes!!!. Will I be back? Absolutely!!!!

Larita Lawson

5 months ago

We had our first visit here with a part of three. Nothing about this place made me think supper club it’s so modern upscale and luxury to me. I loved it on a Saturday they had live jazz LOVED IT! I ordered the ribeye steak with Parmesan crust and it was the best steak I’ve had so delicious juicy flavorful. Sarah was our waitress and did such a great job being an attentive offering suggestions she knows the menu!! I was not a fan of the Mac and cheese it was bland for my liking. The appetizer shrimp and meatballs made up for the Mac!! We will be back!

Leesa Sesing

5 months ago

Had an amazing date night dinner at the Conroy!! The food and service were fantastic. We started with some drinks and apps. For drinks, we tried the desert rose and the old fashioned, both were delish! My boyfriend loves mussels and he ate the entire plate of the saffron mussels. We also tried the caviar flight, loved the concept (I probably would’ve just ordered 3 chips instead of the cucumber). For main course, I had the maple glazed salmon, I would highly recommend trying! The butternut squash with the salmon was the perfect combo. For dessert, we had the crème brûlée!

morgan rhinehart

6 months ago

Had a great time to celebrate my birthday early. The atmosphere,decor, live music, the service and the food were all great. I definitely recommend all that I had tonight ( salmon, forgot the cocktail drink name, mussels, mushrooms and the fries). The service was great ! I adored the live music really set the tone for the venue. I didn’t have to wait long to get each part of what I ordered. The staff are polite, personable, know the food and drinks well to give great recommendations of what pair well together. Also the complimentary birthday cake was delicious. I would recommend going solo or with a group.