Five O'Clock Steakhouse

Jake L

3 months ago

If you’re looking for a true old-school Wisconsin supper club, this is it. Walking through the doors felt like stepping back into the 1950s. The decor, atmosphere, and service all have that classic supper club feel that you just don’t find very often anymore. The food was outstanding. Our family agreed it was the best prime rib and filet we’ve ever had. The Crab Mac & Cheese was an absolute hit as well. Everyone at the table tried it, and we all agreed it was the best crab mac and cheese we’ve ever had. Everything was cooked perfectly, and the portions were generous. One thing to know before you go is that the sides are ordered separately, but they’re huge. We only ordered two sides for our family of five, and it was still more than enough food to share. The service was top-notch from start to finish. Everyone we interacted with was friendly, attentive, and made us feel welcome. One thing I highly recommend is using the complimentary valet parking. We drove around the surrounding area looking for parking before dinner, but we never found a spot where we felt comfortable leaving our truck. The valet was quick, professional, and made the whole experience much easier. We gladly tipped them for the great service. This ended up being one of the highlights of our Milwaukee trip. Between the incredible food, the classic atmosphere, and the outstanding service, it’s a place we’ll definitely return to the next time we’re in town.

Alisha Neinfeldt

4 months ago

Great Wisconsin supper club experience! Chill vibes and loved the entire experience. Drinks at the bar before ordering and then moving to the table with salad and relish try that was delicious. The bread was warm and soft. Our meal came out in perfect timing, steaks cooked to perfection, a baked potato so big it can be shared, and yummy green beans. We passed on dessert because we were full!

Thadd Sapa-Kotlarek

6 months ago

Though my visit was short, I was given the utmost courtesy, and welcomed back with friendly hospitality. Thinking that - after researching the menu with the help of AI and Yelp - squash was being offered, I was surprised to see that I was wrong, but my mistake did not reduce the quality of my experience. Nicole provided the fastest service that I’ve ever received / could’ve believed to be possible at a steakhouse of this nature. - Her performance completely moved my evening along at the pace that I needed, and I want to express my Gratitude. My best wishes to everyone on the serving and kitchen staff. Thank you so much for your care and dedication to our community.

Lysha_Marie

6 months ago

Finally made it to Five O’Clock Steakhouse and it absolutely delivered. Of course I had to get a steak, and it was fantastic. perfectly cooked and exactly what you hope for when you go somewhere known for steak. The sides were great too. One of my favorite parts of the night was the drinks. We tried a few of their ice cream cocktails, including the Pink Squirrel, and they were honestly amazing. Fun, a little nostalgic, and just really well done. The wine was also great, which rounded everything out nicely. The whole place has that classic Milwaukee supper club feel, cozy, a little old-school, and the kind of place where you want to linger and enjoy the night. Really great experience overall and definitely somewhere I’d go back to.