Sullivan's Supper Club

Larry Lindahl

3 months ago

We're old as dirt and are always searching for old style supper clubs. We drove 2 1/2 hours to give Sullivan's a shot and I'm glad we did. Casual place with delicious food. Between us we tried the ribs, tenderloin tips, fish and shrimp. All wonderful, with salad bar and potato included. We had a reservation for opening and the place was packed within 45 minutes. Our server Jill was wonderful, thank you. Looking forward to visiting again this fall so we can sit on the deck and enjoy the beautiful view.

Ellen Killian

4 months ago

Sullivan’s is our GO TO supper club - the owners, the bartenders, wait staff, cooks, bus boys/girls are all top notch! Over the years, we have spent every major celebratory meal at Sullivan‘s! Chris and his staff took over seamlessly from Ed and Sally 25+ years ago. Their steaks are always top notch and tender. They work hard to please you as far as special orders go! I love my salmon blackened, and it is absolutely wonderful. Their consistency on their food and dressings is outstanding and their salad bar always has wonderful choices. I wish they would have chicken dumpling soup more on their salad bar, but that is just a suggestion not a complaint. The key is you need to have a reservation. There was a time that you didn’t need a reservation, but now even though we go about every Friday night from fall to spring, we know to have a reservation — if a family gets turned away because they didn’t have a reservation patrons should not think that is a negative, people should realize how conscientious the owners are and how high they hold the bar for their service and quality - for you to experience! If you’re coming in on a boat, they are happy to pick you up at the marina. I strongly suggest a Tito‘s Cosmo with a lime, a southern comfort, old-fashioned sweet or a Jamison old-fashioned sweet from the bar. Their ice cream drinks are wonderful and enough for people to share. From beginning to end every aspect is absolutely wonderful! Their waitstaff have been employed for many years, that tells you a lot!! Congratulations Chris, you have a wonderful business.