Sturgeon Bay Local
by Local Eyes
Photo: Google

The Mill Supper Club

RestaurantSturgeon Bay, WisconsinHours

Serving traditional supper club fare with a German twist in Sturgeon Bay

CallWebsite

About

The Mill Supper Club is a supper club in Sturgeon Bay offering traditional American dishes and German cuisine. We feature a Friday fish fry menu with cod and shrimp, and our prime rib is cooked medium rare. Our menu also includes chicken schnitzel with spatzel and red cabbage, as well as broiled whitefish. We serve rolls with cinnamon butter. We offer a salad bar with options like liver pate and serve beverages such as Old Fashioneds, cherry cider beers, and Brandy Alexanders. Onion petals are also available as an appetizer with a special sauce. Our building is a historic structure dating from 1930.

Reviews

4.3· 661 reviews
Kate Dubrouskaya
2 months ago

Food was delicious. We came on a Saturday and ordered a prime rib and chicken schnitzel. Both were very delicious. The prime rib was medium rare and very well cooked with me being very soft. The chicken schnitzel had delicious spatzel and red cabbage. I also had a old fashioned which was very delicious! The salad bar was small but adequate. Split pea soup was delicious, maybe a little bit heavy on the ham. We ended our meal with a brandy Alexander which was very good. This was the only supper club we could find in door county that took walk-ins and had availability.

Keri Jensen
2 months ago

I wasn’t so sure about this place at first glance of the menu but boy was I wrong. Everything we had was great and they were so accommodating with our large party of 13. Definitely recommend making a reservation! My sister and cousin loved the different options on the salad bar especially the liver pate. Our waitress was amazing, I think her name was Dana. She was so on top of everything and that place really seems to run like a well oiled machine. I had the seafood platter on Friday fish fry menu. It was so good! I will be dreaming about that cod and shrimp for a while! This place is worth a try and if I am ever in the area again, I would go back!

Nathan C.
4 months ago

Excellent food and reasonable prices. I had the schnitzel sandwich which was delicious. We tried some apps and especially liked the onion petals. The sauce for the onion petals was amazing!

Jennifer Buhr
8 months ago

We had some delicious drinks at the bar first. The salad bar was wonderful. I had the pesto pasta with shrimp and the lemon ginger risotto and both were delicious. My husband had the Cajun shrimp Alfredo and really enjoyed it. Not to mention the prices were reasonable. We will be back.

Review us

Frequently asked

  • What are your hours?

    Local time · GMT-5

    • Mon – TueClosed
    • Wed – Thu4:00 – 8:00 PM
    • Fri – Sat4:00 – 9:00 PM
    • Sunday4:00 – 8:00 PM

Is this yours?

Claim it to update photos, contact details and booking links, and reply to enquiries.

Claim this listing

Find this useful? Sharing helps local places most. How to share