Nightingale Supper Club

Angela Schwingle

a month ago

We went last night to celebrate our anniversary. The prime rib was delicious and our service was good. The sandwiches were okay and they didn't wish us a happy anniversary or do anything even though it was written down at the host station under our reservation so that felt like a bit of a miss. The crab and asparagus soup was very good. They didn't have another soup of the day which was a little bit of a bummer. Overall, it was good, not great.

Nancy Clauss

2 months ago

Steak was fantastic. The soup was sooo good. The chef's special (salmon florentine) was unexpected and quite good. I would say it is an upper scale supper club and highly recommend it.

Brittney Burns Barham

3 months ago

Wonderful, classic supper club in Sturgeon Bay. We enjoyed a great meal on the 4th of July. Definitely try the white fish and make sure and get the cherry pie!!

Lori Oudenhoven

4 months ago

I was raised in Green Bay and have been to Door County countless times, but have never eaten at The Nightingale. I cannot believe I have missed the experience of this wonderful supper club all these years. I went there for dinner on a Friday night and was amazed at the friendly staff, the cleanliness of the restaurant and the great ambiance. We had reservations, but were early so we sat at the bar and I got an Old Fashioned. It was one of the best I have ever had! They had live music, which was a nice touch. We were brought to our table right on time of our reservation. I ordered the perch plate and again, one of the best perch plates I have ever had. Everything was prepared to perfection. My friend got the Ribeye Sandwich and hers was absolutely amazing also. Our waiter was so attentive and the hostess came and chatted with us at the end of our meal. They know what they are doing there and they do it well! I 💯 recommend The Nightingale when visiting Door Country!

Laura Benton

9 months ago

We went for a classic supper club dinner - and we got it! The prime rib was delicious and the Traditional Old Fashioneds were some of the best we’ve ever had. There is a great kids menu but our daughter had the fried shrimp and said it was great. We’ll be back when we’re in the area.