Johnny Manhattan's

Eric Paulsen

2 months ago

Really great all around. None of even got pasta, our friends both got salads they loved and we split a pizza, which was thin crust heaven. Plenty of good choices, and the whole bar and building in general is very nice. Worth the drive from anywhere in the Milwaukee metro.

Nick Kertscher

2 months ago

We had an amazing dining experience! We started with the appetizers, which were fresh, flavorful, and the perfect way to kick off our meal. The steaks were cooked exactly as ordered—tender, juicy, and packed with flavor. What really made the evening special was the staff. Everyone was friendly, attentive, and made us feel welcome from the moment we walked in. The service was outstanding without ever feeling rushed. If you're looking for a great meal with exceptional service, this is definitely a place worth visiting. We'll absolutely be coming back!

Debbie Knee

3 months ago

If you're looking for a great night out for steak dinner, you can't go wrong with Johnny Manhattan's! We had excellent service, great food and extremely friendly people serving. The room we were in was a little loud but we could still hear each other well enough. The managers, Debbie and Zottie were so nice and accommodating! We will definitely be back!

Chris Murphy

4 months ago

Where do I even start with this review? The pork chops. It has to be the pork chops. My parents took me out for a belated birthday dinner while I was back home in my birth state, and after looking over the menu (which was honestly a jaw-dropping experience on its own), I landed on the "Best in Wisconsin" pork chops after plenty of deliberation and some great recommendations from our incredible server, Daniel. Before I go any further, Daniel deserves a huge shoutout—5 out of 5 stars for both service and conversation. He made an already special night even better. The meal started with a Caesar salad, which set the tone nicely, followed by garlic mashed potatoes and warm, chunky cinnamon applesauce. The mashed potatoes were good and complemented the meal well, but that cinnamon applesauce was an unexpected standout. The sweet warmth paired perfectly with the savory flavors of the pork chops. Now for the main event. The entrée comes with TWO 12-ounce pork chops, and you can choose to have them broiled or breaded. Since I couldn't decide, I went with one of each—and I'm glad I did. Both were phenomenal, but the breaded pork chop was on another level. No disrespect whatsoever to the broiled version, which was excellent in its own right, but the breaded chop was one of the best things I've ever eaten. Without exaggeration, these were the best pork chops I've had in my 31 years. They're the kind of dish you think about long after the meal is over. I would genuinely fly across the country to have them again. On a 10 out of 10 scale… I score the pork chops infinity out of 10…. lol….and genuinely & humbly, i’m a harsh food critic!! To top off an already incredible birthday dinner, they surprised me with a complimentary raspberry shortcake for dessert. It was the perfect ending to a fantastic meal and celebration. Johnny Manhattan's absolutely knocked it out of the park and I can’t even tell how excited I am to try the rest of the menu. Anyways, you won't regret going! Pork chops at Johnny Manhattan’s to the moon!!

Jackie Lehnert

10 months ago

Ok, the atmosphere was TOP NOTCH! Definitely a creators go to.. food presentation was beautiful but the taste .... NO... The bake potatoes were still hard, for the price you get a sprinkle of cheese, a pinch of bacon. However the steaks were grade A! The apps were great! We had several, they made us very excited for the main course but we were all so very disappointed. If you go, GO for the VIBE, Apps & Drinks. Stay away from the entrees.