Lehman's Supper Club

Shannon warstler

2 months ago

From the soup, to the salad and main course, everything we ate was wonderful. My chicken and pasta was great! The server was so polite and wanted to make sure my pasta was ok because by the time I got to it, I was only able to eat a few bites of it due to being full. I would def recommend this place to anyone visiting here!!! In looking at a sign inside their entrance, it looks like this place has been in business for almost 100 years! That says a lot, honestly 🥰 Thank you to everyone from the greeter, to the bar staff to our dining room server and chef! Great place with a great selection of dinner items!

Alisha Ostlund

2 months ago

This was my first experience at a Supper Club and I don’t think another could top it! My husband and I celebrated our 15th wedding anniversary dinner on a Saturday in the lounge. Everything was just as it should be! The food was so delicious and generous and I appreciated the time between courses to eat and actually enjoy my meal! It is a true experience- if you’re in a rush I wouldn’t recommend coming, but you’ll be missing out on more then delicious food by skipping the time and enjoyment! At the end of our meal we decided to take dessert to go and we were surprised when the host, servers, and the chef himself! Came out to sing happy anniversary to us with a little sweet sundae! I was delighted, charmed, and sincerely had wonderful time! Everyone who has the time to slow down and enjoy a proper meal should go there! It’s truly special and worth it!

Mj Hart

3 months ago

We went with our Wisconsin Supper Club Enthusiasts group if 10. Everyone enjoyed the experience. Wonderful staff and beautiful dinners. My Mahi Ahi was excellent and all of the dinners being served looked incredible. Servings were ample as well. But the icing on the cake was having the opportunity to meet and talk with the owners. Just wonderful! p.s. Jackie-you are a standout. Excellent at what you do and you made our evening even more fun. You exude hospitality at the highest level.

Jeff Falkner

4 months ago

On 5/30/2026 we had my moms 85th birthday Party at Lehmans supper Club, They catered to 35 guests ,, The owners and staff did an absolute incredible job,, Every meal was done perfectly, I honestly don’t know how they did it ! The servers were all so nice , efficient and friendly ,, I would give Lehmans 10 stars if I could ,, Amazing food , incredible service all for a more then fair price , ohh and the drinks were all incredible,, All our family is still raving about this meal and service by Lehmans !! Thank You so much !! Jeff Falkner , Alaska