Schwarz's Supper Club is a supper club in New Holstein. We are a bustling locale known for our massive steaks and extensive wine list, all served in nostalgic surrounds.
This is one heck of a place. You are catered to every minute. They have some awesome food. Their prime rib is excellent and so is the rest of their food. They had some good local brews and plenty of varying cocktails. I will definitely have to visit again.
Nikki Helms
3 months ago
The service was spectacular! The old fashioneds, onion ring appetizer ave dessert were delicious! I had the prime rib which very well may be my favorite aside from homemade. Only issues were the noise in the dining room and the temperature. It was very cold and it seemed that everyone was shouting which was somewhat overwhelming.
Dave Mayworm
4 months ago
Our first visit was great! The staff was friendly and helpful and the food was great! We will definitely be back.
Colissa Erickson
7 months ago
Best broiled scallops I've had in a while. Had flavor and cooked to perfection. Tenderloin was also cooked exactly as requested. Assorted mushrooms were a definite treat. Had a glass of ice cold milk with my meal. It was a great pleasure to have that kind of option. My favorite thing of all were the baby corn that came with our salad. I have never had corn like that before, so juicy it blew my mind. I could keep going on and on about this place. Great parking, enclosed smoking room with ventilation. Claw machine for the little one ❤️ the only thing I could say to an opposed stand point was the uncertainty of where to go to check in. Nobody greats you and there isnt clarity on where to go. We sat in the middle section of the bar to ask for assistance. Waited for about 10 minutes while others on both sides of us that sat down or came up after us were served before us, over and over like we were invisible. It was Very odd 🤔 Eventually someone greated us and we had a chance to ask and inform them of our 1.5 hour travel and first time visit. Everything after the guidance made up for the awkward uncomfortable entering moments. Probably won't order the calamari again as each bite was inconsistent. One would be good and crunchy and the next would be hard and rubbery or inedible. Other than that, We will definitely come back as our waitress, food and competent chefs have made this a great memory with many more to come.
Review us
Frequently asked
What are your hours?
Local time · GMT-5
Mon – TueClosed
Wed – Thu3:30 – 8:00 PM
Friday3:30 – 8:30 PM
Saturday3:00 – 9:00 PM
Sunday2:30 – 8:00 PM
Is this yours?
Claim it to update photos, contact details and booking links, and reply to enquiries.