First time here. We were passing through on our way home and stopped in for a late afternoon lunch. Food: They have a solid menu with a good variety of breakfast and lunch options. We ordered the patty melt, deep-fried green beans, the fish special (garlic-seared haddock), and finished the meal with a chocolate malt for dessert. The fish dinner came with a small salad, which was a nice way to start the meal. It included a nice mix of fresh vegetables, shredded cheese, and croutons. When the entrée arrived, everything was hot and tasty. The haddock was well seasoned with plenty of garlic, although I would have liked just a bit more searing. The crinkle fries were plentiful and very good. The patty melt was cooked exactly as ordered, medium rare, with a nicely seared patty. The combination of American and Swiss cheese was gooey and delicious, and the marble rye was grilled perfectly. The side of deep-fried green beans was also good, although there was a little more breading than I would have preferred. We noticed they offered shakes and malts, so we saved room for a chocolate malt with extra malt. It was a terrific way to end the meal. They serve it with both the glass and the metal mixing cup, which makes it easy to share. The entire meal was less than $30. It was the best value we found during our entire trip. Service: We received terrific service throughout our visit. Thanks, Mary! She greeted us right away with water and menus and was friendly and helpful from start to finish. Since it wasn't very busy, we even had a chance to enjoy a little conversation with her. She was genuinely pleasant, just like the rest of the staff we encountered. Atmosphere: With a name like Schmitty's, I was expecting more of a bar. Instead, it's a charming small-town café with plenty of personality. The checkerboard floor, red vinyl booth seats, a counter with classic stainless steel stools, and vintage photos on the walls all create exactly the kind of atmosphere I hope to find in a hometown café. This is definitely a place I'd return to. And if you stop in, be sure to ask for Mary. You won't be disappointed.
