St. Paul's Church Thrift Shop

Antiques & SecondhandMilwaukee, WisconsinHours

Offering clothing, jewelry, books, and housewares in Milwaukee

CallWebsite

Follow us

About

St. Paul's Church Thrift Shop is a thrift store in Milwaukee offering a selection of clothing, jewelry, books, and housewares. Our shop provides items for personal use and for resale, with proceeds supporting community initiatives. We accept donations to replenish our inventory for the season. We also host occasional bag sales for a set price. Our team operates on Tuesdays and Saturdays from 10:00 AM to 2:00 PM.

Review us
Rachael Brooke Winkley
7 months ago

One of my favorite thrift shops in town. Great prices, good selection of clothes, jewelry, books, and housewares. The staff is always super friendly.

Mary
7 months ago

I absolutely love this thrift store, and the money goes to the Community, which is more important than the items. The items are absolutely beautiful, and I found an absolute beautiful red and black checkered scarf here for a dollar. Their $10 bag sale is coming up on Tuesday, January 27th, 2026, and again on Saturday, January 31st, 2026. Stuff a bag as much as someone can for $10? Not bad at all, especially if the items are 50 to 75 percent off. I have found vintage Christmas items, which are absolutely beautiful, and I keep saying that I'm not going to this thrift store to shop, but I cave in. I'm glad that I did go this past Saturday, because I found a doll which is a spitting image of my Mother. And the Services at 10:00am on Sunday mornings are absolutely beautiful. Pastor Seth is so nice, as his family. I have been away for about a month, but I plan on coming this coming Sunday for the Service.

Susan Goelz
2 years ago

Saint Paul 's thrift store ♥️ has wonderful items clothing to household items an more stop in 🚶‍♀️ 🚶‍♂️ 🚶‍♀️ 🚶‍♀️ and be amazed the staff are friendly and helpful 😇 😇 happy 🛍 shopping .

Becky Wells
2 years ago

Wow, loved the place instantly. I returned today to do a bit more shopping. It's a 2 hour round-trip drive. As a seller, I'm looking for things worthy of reselling most of the time. I shared my background with a few staff volunteers, & found some beautiful pcs. today. Well, sadly, like most things, after thorough inspection of my purchases when I got home, every single item is damaged 😑 nothing is worthy of resale. Now, I understand the thrift store edict, if you will, & ultimately it's my fault for not having been more careful, but wow... feeling really bummed & a bit miffed as well, especially since there were knowledgeable & aware staff as relates to what I was buying. A loss of about $40 for me all together, including gas. Plus, I brought in a box of donations. No regrets there, but wow... 😔

pajci011
7 years ago

It's a nice and cozy little shop. The employees are polite and kind. The clothing selection (men's and women's) is small compared to other thrifty places, but the quality of the clothing also seems to be above average. Shoe section is small but they vary in nice styles. They've got belts, bowls, vases, cds and a selection of jewelry and baby clothes. There is also a fitting room if you want to try on clothing. Overall, it was a nice little trip. When I went, they had a buy one get one half off clothing promotion, so I got two shirts for seven dollars. However, I do believe they only take cash though, so make sure to have some bills on you when you come in.

Frequently asked

  • What are your hours?

    Local time · GMT-5

    • MondayClosed
    • Tuesday10:00 AM – 2:00 PM
    • Wed – FriClosed
    • Saturday10:00 AM – 2:00 PM
    • SundayClosed

Is this yours?

Claim it to update photos, contact details and booking links, and reply to enquiries.

Claim this listing