Poppy Bakery

Everywhere With Erika

2 months ago

I can't lie, the baked goods we got, all were delicious. The plan was to get the cinnamon roll ONLY, because I heard they were really good. But that display of goodies will suck you right on in...so we ended up getting cookies and a few other baked goods. Now, the cinnamon roll is the truth. Not overly sweet or dry. I tried to eat half and save half for later. I devoured it before the next stop sign. The rest of them baked goods I don't remember their names, because we eat with our eyes. So, we were just point and getting, but yeah this ain't a diet stop. So, wear your bigger britches when you come here.

Eli

3 months ago

Top tier pasties across the board. Came up from Chicago so I got one of everything. Croissants - flakey and perfectly layered. Cookies - perfect texture and balance of sweetness. Savory croissant made me feel like I was eating an entire pasta dish at a fancy restaurant but in croissant form. Brownie - perfect texture and deeply chocolaty without falling into fudge territory. Can’t go wrong!

Cody (Digging In With Cody)

3 months ago

Poppy Bakery on Milwaukee’s east side is a fantastic bakery! I got myself a brownie and a brown butter miso cookie! The brownie was sweet (not overly), and moist! I loved the contrast with the salt on top. The brown butter miso cookie was fresh out the oven, and was soft in the middle and full of that brown buttery goodness. So good! I’ll definitely be back to order some more sweets!

Nicole Felix Bostock

6 months ago

Poppy Bakery is the real deal. You can taste the care in every detail, from the locally sourced ingredients to the beautifully crafted pastries. Each one is complex, balanced, and full of character, offering something new with every bite. It’s the kind of place that turns a simple bakery visit into a memorable experience.

Jay Kay

8 months ago

Easily takes the spot as the best bakery I’ve been to in & around Milwaukee. Got multiple items to try out and everything was delicious and moist. I don’t even like olives but still loved the focaccia bread I got for someone else. Will definitely be back to try other items