Turn Key Supper Club… where we came for dinner and accidentally found the cast of the greatest sitcom in Wisconsin. First, trust your hosts. When they tell you to try the pickle beer, don’t ask questions—just embrace the pickle. Somehow it works, and now I’m questioning everything I thought I knew about beer. The food? Outstanding. Every recommendation was a home run, and we left wondering why we don’t have a place like this back home. But the real stars of the night were “T” for Tanner, Simon, and Madonna. Their personalities are worth the trip alone. They had us laughing all morning and made us feel like regulars on our very first visit. And one final request to management: whatever you do, do NOT make Simon cut his hair. That hair is part of the brand at this point. It’s legendary, instantly recognizable, and deserves employee status all by itself. Let it flow! It makes him unforgettable, and now everyone needs to stop by Turn Key just to meet the guy with the epic hair. Great food, great drinks, unforgettable people, and enough laughs to burn off at least one cheese curd. We’ll definitely be back!
