Toby's Supper Club

Connie Corrigan

2 months ago

Classic food in a homey environment. Glad they could squeeze me in as I didn't have a reservation. Shrimp are huge! Make sure you add them to your order.

Dania Sopher

2 months ago

We're out-of-towners and this was our first Supper Club experience. We were confused about the ins-and-outs of navigating the experience. We asked some people near the bar for guidance, and they were extremely hospitable. Everything was delicious! We had cheese curds (squeaky-fresh perfection), chicken tortilla soup, walleye, and perch. We took the cinnamon rolls with us (we were stuffed), and enjoyed them for breakfast the next day. Numerous guests at tables nearby chatted with us, and the couples who helped us when we first arrived stopped by our table on their way out to check in with us (we 💛 Wisconsinites). Altogether, it was a great meal and an amazing social Supper Club experience that we highly recommend to others! ***For Newbies (like us): Don't stand around waiting for someone to greet/seat you. When you arrive, head straight to the bar and order your drinks (alcoholic or non-alcoholic). Let the bartender know if you're planning to eat, and they'll give you a menu. You can sit at the bar or at one of the high tops in the bar area. You'll have to pay the bartender for the drinks you had at the bar, and the rest of your meal will be on the bill delivered by your server. While you enjoy your drinks in the bar area, your server will come by to take your food order. Our appetizer was delivered to us while we were in the bar, and later our sever returned to take us to our table in the dining room. A relish tray, rolls, and soup were set up and waiting for us and entrees were delivered later.

Paula Szekely

3 months ago

We came from out of town and wanted to experience a traditional supper club. Family suggested Toby's and we were not disappointed. The atmosphere was cozy and comfy. The server was on fire and we never saw her stop. The meal was a delicious cornucopia of dishes. From the drinks, rolls, relish tray, cinnamon rolls, sides, steaks, and perch we were impressed.

Allie Kreuz

4 months ago

Such a fun and delicious supper club experience! The steaks are okay, but the real thing to get is the fish or shrimp! Best fried shrimp you’ll ever find! Great drinks, food and portions at good prices, and everyone who works there is very friendly. We went 2 weeks in a row and had Krista and Danielle as servers and both were fantastic. Danielle will give you all the best advice- just let her order for you!

Marie Putt

8 months ago

Saturday they open at 3 taking in the experience! We know they get busy with no host or take reservations! So with that said we wanted to get there early to get a table. Well they make a lot of old fashions drinks very tasty! Well they don’t start serving food till 5 so about 4:30 they take your order at the bar and sit you at the table when your food is ready! They have a system! Our waitress was so nice definitely a different experience!