Maple Tree Supper Club

RestaurantMadison, WisconsinHours

Serving American comfort chow with a salad bar and Sunday breakfast

CallWebsite

Follow us

About

Maple Tree Supper Club is an American restaurant in McFarland. We plate comfort chow and offer a salad bar, plus we serve Sunday breakfast.

Logan Hilgart
3 months ago

My fiancée and I went to Maple Tree Supper Club for their prime rib special, and overall we had a great experience. The only downside was our interaction with the hostess when we first arrived. She came across as rude and condescending when I asked about where we could sit, which was a disappointing way to start the night. That being said, our server was amazing. She was very attentive, friendly, and helpful, and she made sure we got our food quickly. The prime rib was excellent, and for the price, it’s a great deal for what you get. Overall, the food, value, and service from our waitress were all great. Aside from the hostess experience at the beginning, we really enjoyed our visit and would come back for the prime rib special.

R H
9 months ago

Maple Tree Supper Club was my partners choice for her birthday dinner as she had never been there and I had been there only once many years ago for a banquet. The parking seemed pretty full when we pulled in however when we walked in the door the hostess took us right to a table for 2 and I could see that they were about 3/4s full. So don't let the parking being full fool ya when you get here. Our server was at our table very quickly with menus and silverware and took our drink orders which were a pepsi for me and brandy old fashioned sweet for her I also ordered some onion rings as an appetizer and we checked out the menu while she got our drinks. When she brought our drinks she also brought water which someplace don't do anymore unless you ask which is a nice touch of service she also brought a small warm loaf of bread another nice touch. We put in our orders which were the Swiss steak with mashed potatoes for her and the 8oz top sirloin with a baked potato these both came with a trip to the salad and soup bar. The salad bar was very good with a good and fresh selection to put on your plate and an assortment of dressings. The soup choices were vegetable beef and bacon cheddar potato and both were excellent and I believe made from scratch. We had just finished our soup and salad when our entrees came from the kitchen. My steak was perfectly medium rare with a nice char and tender and juicy and the au jus that was served with it was excellent. My partner said the Swiss steak was also great. Her mashed potatoes and my baked potato excellent as well oh and the small warm loaf of bread brought early was very good. We ended up taking half of each of our orders home with us along with about half the onion rings appitizer which by the way were also very both when they were served and when I reheated them in the air fryer. Our took great care come around several times to check on how the food was tasting and to check on drink refills as well as bringing a small carafe of water. It was an excellent meal and great service and not at an unreasonable price. We will be back to the Maple Tree again in the future. Sorry I didn't take any interior photos as there were a lot folks having dinner i didn't want to bother anyone.

Bekka Rodgers
11 months ago

Just like always- but better! Plan on a wait for a table on Fridays- We enjoyed some fantastic cocktails on the outdoor patio for about an hour and a half- just perfect. When we got to the table, the service was top- notch. The food was well prepared and the portions were great! Welcome back! Kudos to the new owners!!

Jerry Murphy
a year ago

It is slightly different than other supper clubs we have been to. No dark walls, no relish tray. And had to wait 45 minutes ( before 5:30 on a Thursday, after being told it would be 30 minutes ). BUT, having said that, we had an outstanding meal of Petite Prime Rib, with all the fixings. And our server, Alley, was very good. She made us feel appreciated personally. Do try Maple Tree, but go early and be prepared to wait. But it will be worth it. Oh, and I had a chocolate-covered strawberry martini. It was fabulous.

Adam Derringer
2 years ago

Real happy Maple Tree was able to open after their fire. After the reopening Maple is a little cleaner and more modern but they did not change a lot and it is still a supper club. The bar is very busy and quite tight. They have steaks, prime, fish, chicken, sandwiches, and more. My prime was just okay, wanted rare, it wasn't. Wife's tenderloin was fine but not great. What stood out, they have a great salad bar with 2 soups...lots of supper clubs have cut their salad bars so I really appreciate they brought it back. I plan to stop here again.

Review us

Frequently asked

  • What are your hours?

    Local time · GMT-5

    • MondayClosed
    • Tue – Thu4:00 – 8:30 PM
    • Fri – Sat4:00 – 9:30 PM
    • SundayClosed

Is this yours?

Claim it to update photos, contact details and booking links, and reply to enquiries.

Claim this listing

Find this useful? Sharing helps local places most. How to share