Brandy's Old Fashioned Supper Club & Cocktails

Vera Byrne

2 months ago

andy's Old Fashioned is a must-visit if you're in the Lake Geneva area. The atmosphere perfectly captures the warmth and nostalgia of a true Wisconsin supper club, making the experience feel both unique and authentic. The service was exceptional— friendly, attentive, and fast. Be sure to order the Grasshopper milkshake; it's absolutely delicious and unlike any other I've tried. This place exceeded our expectations, and I can't wait to return.

Geetha Fisher

8 months ago

So we went back and we were delighted with the service. The food was amazing and this has to be our new fav place to frequent. We already knew the old fashioneds were delish. We had the blacked shrimp with Cajun rice, one of the best Cajun rice I have ever sampled. We also had to try the cheese curds which were really good paired with the aioli dip. I had the broasted chicken with potato pancakes and spicy slaw, so yum. The pancakes are massive and I could eat only part of one. Chicken was so flavorful! The boys all had the Friday fish fry and of course I had to try it. So flaky so crunchy , a must try. To wrap and I couldn't get pics coz it got devoured, we had the raspberry cheese cake and creme brulee. The cheese cake was unique and oh- so good!! Check this place out , and oh they take reservations which I did not realize!! ------------------------------------ My earlier review: Our first time and definitely will be back. We stopped at the bar. So glad we did Good Brandy old Fashioned. Loved the atmosphere, the setting. Will be back to try food. Service was a miss. But we believe in second chances so not a show stopper unless a repeat

David Hanson

a year ago

Stopped in for dinner while my wife and I were on our honeymoon and we couldn’t be happier with our experience. Everyone who we talked with was extremely kind and personable, and our server Steven was amazing. He convinced us to try a Golden Cadillac ice cream drink, which I had never heard of, but it was very good and I would recommend it to anyone. We got the shrimp scampi and the Brandy’s chicken, both were very good. Thank you for the great experience! Was definitely a highlight of our trip.