Old Abe's Supper Club

RestaurantJim Falls, WisconsinHours

Hearty supper club dishes and an open salad bar in Jim Falls

Call

Follow us

About

Old Abe's Supper Club is a restaurant in Jim Falls serving a range of supper club favorites including apple pork loin, ground sirloin steak, and prime rib. We offer an open salad bar with every meal. Our bar area provides spacious seating, and some back tables overlook an open field. We are known for our square cheese curds and dessert drinks like the pink squirrel. Our team serves Friday fish fry and old fashions.

Jamie Bischel
2 months ago

I've lived in this area all my life and never been here. Set on a back road between Eaglton and Jim Falls. Was a good option for an anniversary dinner. I had the apple pork loin 6oz with lyanised Hashbrowns. It was very good. Hashbrowns were not burnt, which I find in most cases when ordering them from other restaurants. The meat was juicy and tender. Not over done to be like mush and not under cooked to be like chewing gum. It was loaded with cooked apples that I could have had a second helping of!! My husband had the ground sirloin steak. ( we are not steak people) Didn't realize it was going to come out like a hamburger with no bun! But it was good and juicy. Had it cooked medium-well. Also had the lyanized potatoes. When going back he said he will just get the sirloin steak. Portions were plenty. Also had an open salad bar which you get when ordering the meal. The seating was ok. I did kinda feel a little close with the other patrons. The place overall was nice, had feeling of, this place has been here a while but not a run down shack. If you are lucky enough to get a back table there is windows to look out that overlook an open field, which at the time had deer in it. When entering the establishment, you first enter the bar. Seemed spacious with plenty of seating around the bar. And adequate standing room. We were told a 10 minute wait for a table. We ordered a drink and were seated in about 5. There was not a huge menu of options but a little of everything to choose from, and a kids menu. Staff was very friendly and overall atmosphere was nice, and casual. We will be going back.

Malachi Stanley
4 months ago

I have been dating my partner for almost a year now. And ever since our first phone call, she has been telling me about the infamous Wisconsin supper club. So, this weekend, I finally got the opportunity to go. Being a North Carolina boy, I had an idea of what I was in for, and I was right. A homey, quaint little place, making good food for good people to share. I appreciated that they had the story of “Old Abe” on the menu; it was cool to read about the bird that followed around the troops and lifted their spirits. The thing I noticed almost instantly was the camaraderie and friendship among the patrons and bartenders; had there not been cash or debit cards present, I would have thought it was a large get-together with friends, all having a great time. After an hour of drinks, we were set at our table. I got the prime Rib, which came with the salad bar. It was a great experience, especially with the cheese spread and crackers that I was introduced to. While the prime rib was good, the real star of the show was the square cheese curds. While we were ordering, one of my partner's relatives asked me if I had had the square curds yet, and when I told him no, he said I had to try them, and people, let me tell you, get the damn square curds. Holy rusted metal batman, were they good! After the great meal, I was told that we had to get a dessert drink, so of course I obliged. My partner got a pink squirrel, and we split it. Clearly being a North Carolina boy, I had no idea what a “pink squirrel” was, but damn, it was tasty. I cannot remember exactly what was in there, but I will be asking my soon-to-be relatives for a general recipe so I can recreate this at home!

Brian Dunham
5 months ago

We had a great time. Friday fish, strong pours, friendly staff. Will be back again!

Rich Martinez
10 months ago

Enjoyed my evening at this “Friday Fish Fry Supper Club”. Thank you Hannah for your hospitality and I hope you get a deer tomorrow morning! The food was delicious and the old fashions were perfect! Rebecca my server was incredible!! Thank you to everyone!!

Molly M
3 years ago

Come early! We get there when the doors open on Friday so we don't have to wait. Have always gotten the fried cod. Really nice salad bar with soup. The drinks are cheap and the grasshopper & pink squirrel are really really good!

Review us

Frequently asked

  • What are your hours?

    Local time · GMT-5

    • Mon – TueClosed
    • Wed – Thu4:30 – 10:00 PM
    • Fri – Sat4:30 – 10:30 PM
    • Sunday3:00 – 9:00 PM

Is this yours?

Claim it to update photos, contact details and booking links, and reply to enquiries.

Claim this listing
Call

Find this useful? Sharing helps local places most. How to share