Tally Ho Supper Club

Carolyn Martin

4 weeks ago

We have been going to this restaurant for 30+ years. We've seen a few changers in ownership, but have really enjoyed their food. Its pricey, but excellent! Our waitress was tentatively, even though she was the only one working. Highly recommend for a special occasion!

judy sperry

a month ago

Took a little while to be seated. After being seated service was over the top. Absolutely loved the glass my Cosmo came in. It was perfect. Root vegetable medley was great. Filet and sea bass were very good. We have passed by this place for years and never stopped. Our bad. We felt pretty special as guests.

Megan vdm

3 months ago

I’ve been visiting Hayward area for 30 + years. This was my first trip and not my last to Tally Ho! Classic supper club relish tray, fantastic garlic rolls! Nice salads, would love to see homemade dressings on them instead. Got the stuffed mushrooms which were great! We had the queen cut prime rib which was great, just missing horseradish sauce.

Kelsey Bassett

4 months ago

There’s just something about an old school Wisconsin supper club that feels like stepping into another era… and Tally Ho nailed it ! From the second we walked in, you could feel the pride behind this place. The owner was incredibly kind and genuinely cared about every detail of the experience and the menu. A true family establishment. Even his grandsons were there working, which made the whole place feel even more special and welcoming. The ambiance was everything I want in a supper club. Sinatra photos lining the walls. Crooners playing softly over the speakers. The cool patterned carpet. The black upholstered leather bar. Even the custom matchbooks at the front felt like such a classic touch and honestly made me smile. Little details like that just make a place feel memorable. It felt nostalgic in the best possible way. And let’s talk about the food… No popovers? Honestly… popovers who? 😂 The fresh homemade bread was OUT OF THIS WORLD. Warm, soft, buttery perfection. I also loved the relish tray. Almost everything was made in house and you could absolutely taste the difference. Our meals were incredible from start to finish, and somehow we still saved room for dessert. The peach cobbler and strawberry shortcake were both so good. Tally Ho is one of those places you leave already planning your next visit. We will absolutely be back. ❤️

Schellie

7 months ago

Had great old fashioneds at the bar. A phenomenal relish tray with garlic butter buns. Main course was prime rib & ribeye with blue cheese butter. Dessert was courtesy of Venture Wisconsin Supper Club book! This was a fun stop with amazing staff & felt so cozy!