Relish Supper Club

Sarah Jajtner

2 months ago

We just had the Clubhouse burger. I think the best burger we have had in our lives. We also got the chicken cordon bleu which was amazing as well! Last was the peach bourbon which was great! We will be back!

Eve Kosol

3 months ago

Supper club in German town with a fun atmosphere and good food. 4.5 stars Food: 4.25 Service: 5 Atmosphere: 4.5 Cost to worth it rating: 3 Opentableable: no but on Toasttab Return worthiness: yes Highlights: - Coconut shrimp: special app had plump shrimp and crispy coconutty exterior. Always order this when I see it on a menu and this was a great version. 4.5 stars - Cheese curds: light breading and gooey as they should be. 4.25 stars - Old fashioneds: several different versions. I enjoyed the pineapple and the relish one with brandy and bourbon. 4.25 stars - Relish bar: thick sesame rods, Wisconsin cheddar cheese spread and butter in personalized portions, veggies, some meat. Pretty fun. 4 stars - Caesar salad: Fresh and tangy with shaved large thin slices of Parmesan. 4 stars Rib and filet combo: nice to get a variety. Ribs were tender and meaty and steak was cooked to order. 4 stars - Atmosphere: sizable rectangular bar with TVs all around upon entry and dining room farther in with animal heads on the walls - Staff: Diane the GM was super friendly - Pull tabs: machines to play and redeem Lowlights: - We didn't have the largest appetite so we didn't get to order the French onion soup and snapper we wanted to

Vicki Spencer

6 months ago

We had our first visit for our 10 year wedding anniversary and it was fantastic! We love to try new super clubs and this one did not disappoint! The staff, relish bar and food were wonderful. Thank you for a lovely experience!

Scott W

6 months ago

First time here. It was a Wednesday night, and we had a 6:00 reservation for eight. Food: We gathered at the bar before dinner and had a drink. They have a nice selection of cocktails, including several Old Fashioneds. A few of us got the Blackberry Old Fashioned, which was very good. We skipped appetizers and decided to order our dinners right away. They offer a nice variety of entrees and portion sizes, so there’s something for everyone. Our table ordered Clubhouse Burgers, ribs, salmon, and a filet. While we were waiting, they brought out a couple of loaves of warm bread with butter, which was perfect for snacking. Bottom line, everyone was very happy with their meal. Someone even said it was the best salmon they had ever had. My Clubhouse Burger was cooked to order, medium rare. It was flavorful and served hot. The fries were just okay and could have been hotter. Portion sizes for all the entrees were generous, and most of us ended up asking for to-go containers. For dessert, they have a nice selection. A couple of us ordered the layered chocolate cake, and someone got a Brandy Alexander (they also offer ice cream drink flights). The chocolate cake was good but had way too much mousse filling, and I like mousse. The Brandy Alexander was perfectly made and not overblended. Service: Everyone we interacted with was super friendly and helpful. The hosts, bartenders, and servers were all outgoing and did a great job connecting with our group. Orders were taken efficiently, and the food was served promptly. We had a bit of a celebration and presentation for one member of our group, and the staff was very accommodating and respectful of that. Overall, a great crew. Atmosphere: It has the feel of a classic supper club. The woodwork, fireplace, taxidermy, and design elements make you feel like you’re up north in the middle of a forest. It’s a great vibe, and the place is well maintained. A couple of things that could be tweaked: They offer a relish buffet in the bar area. I initially thought it was complimentary, but it turns out it’s meant to be ordered as part of your meal and costs $5 per person. I’ve never been charged for a relish tray at a supper club, so this stood out. Personally, I’d prefer a complimentary relish tray at the table. Overall: I was impressed with the entire experience and would definitely go back.

Natasha Lindow

7 months ago

My husband and I came here this week to celebrate our wedding anniversary. It was our first visit to the establishment. We live in the city, so we are used to being waited on and cared about while dining out. We were seeking a new experience from city offerings. We have had several friends come out there to eat and said good things. We were excited to try it. The relish buffet is very cute and a good way to start the meal. Did not like the deviled eggs though. We ordered some appetizers next. Tried the cheese curds which were phenomenal but didn’t like the sauce, just used ranch from the relish buffet on that. He ordered the onion rings. We had our salads next. I enjoyed the wedge salad. Good flavor on the candied bacon crumbles. Staff attentive and helpful. Meals came out hot and fresh. I had the pan friend shrimp and he ordered the ribeye steak. I thought his steak was a little chewy but he liked it. It wasn’t the most premier cut of beef but it wasn’t my entree. I loved the shrimp, they were large size! Our table was decorated for anniversary and the server brought us a free chocolate cake. Drinks and food were good here. Worth the drive from the city. Make a reservation, you won’t be disappointed. Only issue I had was no one in the dining room was dressed nicely except us. Everyone here wears jeans and casual clothing which is tacky at a supper club.