Sorella | Italian

Molly Arnason

a month ago

Sorella is serving some of the best Italian food in the Three Lakes/Eagle River area! Everything we ordered was delicious, and it’s clear they take pride in what they serve. The homemade pasta is absolutely delicious, and the arancini are a must-try! They also have a fantastic wine list, making it a great choice for a special occasion. Definitely worth a visit if you’re in the area! Be sure to make a reservation, as it can be difficult to get a table without one.

Troy Flugaur

a month ago

Very cool place tucked away in the north woods. Awesome Italian food. The cocktails were also great. I got the pasta Salsiccia and my wife got the linguine with clams. We also got the garlic shrimp as an appetizer. It was the best pasta we have had in a long time, only time it was better was in some small towns in Italy. The place was intimate and really nice. Truly a gem in Eagle River. Do yourself a favor and try it, you won’t regret it.

Don Esposito

2 months ago

July 21, 2026 My wife and I went to Sorella yesterday to celebrate her birthday. I ordered the bolognese with gnocchi, she had the filet mignon. Her steak was excellent and a surprisingly large portion done perfectly to her liking with potato and sautéed patty pan squash on the side. The bolognese was good with lots of meat to balance out the tomato sauce. My only complaint would be that the sauce was a bit too acidic for my liking. We split a tiramisu for dessert and it was very good. I have to say that there was one thing that bugged me though. Every Italian restaurant I’ve ever been to provides extra virgin olive oil and grated cheese on the table. It’s there when you first sit down and it stays there for you to use throughout your meal until they clear the table for dessert. We were informed that we could have oil with our bread for an extra charge so I didn’t even ask if I could have extra cheese. Our server, Colin, was great: Attentive without being overbearing. I like that. We will definitely go back again. There were a lot of other items on the menu that I want to try.

Jamie Norton

3 months ago

Everytime we are in or around Eagle River we come here! The food is always so delicious and full of flavor. Not pictured is their salad (which comes with the meal and is my fav!) Also comes with focaccia bread. Everything is made fresh! Always a great meal start to finish!!

Anthony Westfall

9 months ago

Easily the best food we’ve had in a long time! I have to have the carpaccio every time I come back it was so good. All the food was amazing and timed perfectly. Pinot Noir was incredible and we loved our service. Filet was unreal, so good!