Slinger Local
by Local Eyes
Photo: Google

Out of the Box Baking - A Momma Meyer Co.

BakerySlinger, WisconsinHours

Local bakery bakes from 6 AM on weekdays and 7 AM on Sundays

CallWebsite

About

Out of the Box Baking is a local bakery that specializes in cake pops, offering a variety of flavors beyond traditional cakes. They also provide custom-decorated cake pops for special occasions, such as weddings and parties, ensuring a personalized touch for any event. Customers consistently praise the moistness and flavor of their cake pops, noting the generous portion sizes. The bakery focuses on creating delicious treats that are both satisfying and artfully presented. Reviews highlight their excellent communication and seamless ordering process, making it easy for customers to get exactly what they envision. It's a perfect spot for everyday treats or significant celebrations.

Reviews

5.0· 9 reviews
Review us
Jensen Meyer
9 months ago

We had Out Of the Box Baking provide cake pops for our wedding, and they were an absolute hit! Not only were they beautifully decorated to match our theme, but they were also delicious—moist, flavorful, and loved by guests of all ages. We received so many compliments on them throughout the night. The ordering process was smooth, communication was easy, and everything was ready on time. We couldn’t have been happier with how it all turned out. Highly recommend for weddings, parties, or any special occasion!

Isabella Mraz
9 months ago

I had a stuffed s’mores cake pop and it was delicious! The cake was moist, and the portion size was great; so many cake pops tend to be so small for the price. I was so happy with mine, it was a great nod to a s’more while still being a tasty cake treat.

Alaina M
5 months ago

I ordered my friend's wedding cake through Out of the Box Baking and it was perfect in every way- delicious cake, excellent communication and the owner spent time making sure she was getting the order exactly how I envisioned it. Thank you so much!

Pang Thao
9 months ago

I thoroughly enjoyed my Pumpkin Spice cake pop! It was moist, a flavorful spice that did not taste artificial, and was a nice portion. It is larger than most cake pops and is a delight especially when my family does not like pumpkin. This allows me to have something special for myself! It’s a must try especially as the fall season is upon us.

Frequently asked

  • What are your hours?

    Local time · GMT-5

    • Mon – Wed6:00 AM – 5:00 PM
    • Thu – Sat6:00 AM – 10:00 PM
    • Sunday7:00 – 11:00 AM

Is this yours?

Claim it to update photos, contact details and booking links, and reply to enquiries.

Claim this listing