Eaton's Fresh Pizza - Take 'n Bake - North Side Sheboygan

Michael Kraig Beeck

a month ago

Stopped and had a fantastic experience. The staff was incredibly friendly, welcoming, and made the whole visit easy from start to finish. Great service, convenient takeout, and delicious pizza. Definitely be back!

George Mueller

a month ago

This past Friday was my first time ordering from here. I ordered 5 different pizzas and they were all delicious and priced right. I live a little while away, but will definitely order again when I'm in the Sheboygan area.

Tyler Wychesit

a month ago

I've been here twice at the time of writing this review. Both times, the pizza has been excellent. The ingredients all taste real and fresh, the sauce they have is amazing and the service has been incredibly quick and friendly. There are several items ready for purchase on the tables/coolers as soon as you walk in. You can purchase frozen pizzas, breads, apps and cheeses if you'd like. They also have a number of their own products available like their pizza topper and pizza steels/plates for a few dollars for properly baking your pizza in the event you don't already have one. You can order fresh-made pizzas online or use the kiosk in-store and it will be ready incredibly quickly. The pricing is also fantastic considering what you're getting. I'll be returning here often.

Deb VS

3 months ago

What a wonderful experience. I heard great things about the pizza. I placed an order online, very quick & easy. You can pay at time of order or on pickup. I really like that option. When I picked up the woman working greeted me immediately with a GENUINE welcome. I let her know it was the first time trying the pizza. She said, we'll see you again. She was RIGHT, they will be seeing me again. The pizza was delicious! Cracker thin crust(they have other crust options), generous toppings & great pricing! I hope they open another location closer to Falls, but definitely worth the trip. I had ordered a Hawaiian 12" & a 14" pepperoni w/dbl fresh mushrooms. The total under $25! I'm so excited to have found this place. You can't get a decent frozen pizza for that price.

Hannah Radschlag

5 months ago

Had their Mac and Cheese and added pepper jack cheese and bacon to it and the Wisconsin Cheesesteak. Both were absolutely delicious 😋 I can't wait to have these again and also try their other options! Will definitely be stopping by when I'm in the area!