Maggie McFly's | Middlebury

Maria Giugno

2 months ago

Maggie McFly's never disappoints! The food was absolutely amazing, the portions were huge, and everything came out fresh and full of flavor. We ordered the Kids Hot Dog, Teriyaki Bowl, Chicken Parmigiano, and the Chicken Milanese, and every dish was excellent. The teriyaki bowl was packed with chicken and vegetables, the parmigiano was loaded with cheese and sauce, and the Milanese was perfectly crispy with a delicious creamy sauce and fresh arugula on top. Even the kids' meal was a generous portion. The service was just as impressive. Our server Emily was fast, friendly, and attentive, making sure we had everything we needed without ever feeling rushed. It's refreshing to find a place that delivers both quality food and great hospitality. If you're looking for delicious food, generous portions, and excellent service, Maggie McFly's is definitely worth a visit. We left full, happy, and already looking forward to coming back. At Maggie's, "one serving" could comfortably feed a small village. In this case, I'm not complaining we have lunch and dinner for the following day!

Don Valentine

2 months ago

Stopped here while traveling for work. It's a great spot with a great menu! I ordered from the seasonal menu. I ordered the Korean bao buns as my app, and the steak frites for my main. It was all very delicious. Server was great, very attentive to refilling my drink, even though I ordered diet Coke, she didnt tell me they only have Pepsi products. There is a vast different in flavor from Diet Coke to Diet Pepsi. Most servers will ask "is Diet Pepsi ok?" If they don't have Diet Coke, to which I would have chosen a different drink.

Janet Gipson

3 months ago

This is a frequent dinner/Happy Hour spot for us. Food and drinks are consistent and there are SO many choices! And, the portions are such that I can always count on lunch the next day! This is HALF of the Kale Quinoa Salad with Grilled Chicken. Delish! Update: 5/23/26 We continue to come weekly and typically sit at the bar. In fact, we won't stay if we can't. We know the bar staff pretty well. Tony, by far, is the most attentive, competent and friendly. We know when he works and try to make sure that's when we go. I wish the service was more consistent. Perhaps they will train others to a better standard of service.

Linfire Quinones

3 months ago

This come from a food lover... but I totally recommend this place. Burgers are big,meaty, satisfying and tasty, fries are even better than any fast food, onion rings are the best I ever had and the waitress was the best I ever had, she was professional and very polite. Would I come back? Absolutely! Definitely recommending this place to my friends and family.♥︎ thank you for giving me the best experience Maggie McFly's.

A.S Psychic

3 months ago

Delicious food!! I recommend "La Paella" it has a subtle kick and that makes it absolutely delicious. The "Teriyaki bowl with Lo-mein" has plenty of vegetables and that makes it a good balanced main course. The sangria was spot on with the right amount of sweetness it made me feel as I had traveled abroad.