Mitch's Sports Cards & Collectibles

Thomas Lepak

4 months ago

The Customer service and experience is top notch. They have the best selection and are very willing to help if brand new into the hobby as well. Will be coming back.

Zig Justice

8 months ago

This store is outstanding. They've got a big selection of stuff, both sports and TCG, but Mitch and Cullen are heroes when it comes to helping people grow, sell, and otherwise enjoy their collections. They're not just running a business; they're enthusiasts themselves, not to mention friendly and incredibly helpful. They'll help with card grading, or selling collectibles, and offer services for selling things on auction on consignment. Solidly reliable, too. I stopped in because I was hoping to sell some high-value collectible TCG stuff I had. I had contacted other stores, but nobody else was willing to work with such high value items. Mitch got back to me literally the next morning with a buyer lined up, and they handled shipping, insurance, and communicating with the buyer. Since they've got a lot of connections in the collectible card industry, and are comfortable with and competent in handling high value collectibles, they're definitely a trustworthy resource and provide an immeasurable amount of added value for someone like me who doesn't have any reputation on auction sites and struggles with shipping and insuring collectibles. 100% worth a visit, and they're going to be my first stop from now on when it comes to buying and selling!

Kyle Sheane

9 months ago

Very Nice Store with a huge selection of sealed product. The guy working Cullen is very knowledgeable and courteous while answering all my questions. I will be coming back.

Aaron S

9 months ago

It's a breaker studio with a couple hundred Wisconsin-centric Bucks, Brewers, Packers slabs. I've been there three times. The atmosphere is two guys loudly hyping each other up in a backroom doing live breaks, and one disinterested employee that is usually in the back office. They have ~90,000 eBay sales and the "store" is a lifeless add-on to their actual breaking business. Prices are 10-20% higher than buying product online from reputable vendors. Example: 2025 Topps Sapphire Hobby was priced $120 higher than online vendors. Inventory is 95% from the 2020's and sealed boxes are sparse. Zero junk wax. A few $2 and $5 boxes, no set building cards. It's a breakers office that barely passes as a card shop.

Karen Heller

11 months ago

Great experience selling vintage baseball card with Cullen at Mitch's Sports Cards! I wanted to sell my dad's vintage baseball card, but had no idea what it was worth or how to sell it. Other shops told me to get the card graded. They either had no interest in the raw card, or would pay a few hundred for it. But when I called Mitch's and talked to Cullen, he convinced me it would be worth it to have it graded. Then he went above and beyond, offering to send it in for me. Who does that?! He could have bought it cheap, then had it graded and sold it himself. His integrity is remarkable! Not only that, but he gave me solid advice on selling the card - best method and how to price it. All his recommendations were spot on, resulting in a quick sale at a high price. He kept me informed during the process, was always responsive via text, and patient with my questions. I highly recommend doing business with Cullen. He's a really nice, helpful guy you can trust to buy/sell cards.