Kelly's Pot Pies & More - Greenfield

Robin Reid

3 months ago

Always wanted to try this place based on the reviews but don’t live close. Was in area so decided to place an order online. You can order the meat pies frozen or par baked and good to go. Went with the chicken pot pie as we order it whenever we see it on a menu. It had plenty of white meat chicken in it, potatoes, carrots and peas. Was very good and filling. Also tried the lemon torte, was delicious as well. Had curbside pickup, as soon as I pulled up the owner/ manager came out of the store with my order from the description I gave of my car online with my order and a punchcard for purchases to go toward free product once the card is filled. Will have to drive a bit next time but worth the drive to load up on frozen chicken pot pies.

Karen Anderson

6 months ago

We absolutely love Kelly’s Pot Pies! Each one (large or small) is filled to the top with delicious meats & veggies, etc., and the crust is flaky. They are simply the best! We’ve gotten chicken in the past, but are starting to try others. Turkey is next on our menu. I think after that, we’ll try the pizza pie. Yum!!

Laura Butler

7 months ago

Kelly's has a wide variety of pot pies always available. Both fresh and frozen options are usually available. These are very generously filled. I enjoy many of the desserts. Recently had a slice of lemon torte. It was wonderful! I will definitely splurge and get that again. I'm a frequent buyer of the Wisconsin Pure Maple Syrup at Kelly's also.

Lindsey

a year ago

We got the brat pie from the Waukesha Farmer’s Market. It’s absolutely to die for! The crust is delicious and so flaky and combining that with the beer flavor and brats, is fantastic! We will be getting these regularly on football Sundays. 10/10 would recommend.

Marcello Mendez

a year ago

I got the veggie and the chicken options, and both are delicious! I had to put my fork down for a moment because I forgot to snap a photo, but trust me, you won’t be let down. You can really savor all the flavors in each dish. They come into options cooked or frozen. I chose the Frozen option because it was fresh out the oven after 60 minutes of baking. I also needed something sweet, so I went for the cheesecake, and it hit all the right notes for me. I’ll definitely be back to sample the other pot pies they have!