St Mary's Thrift Shop

Antiques & SecondhandElm GroveHours

Curated selection of thrifted items in Elm Grove

About

St Mary's Thrift Shop is a thrift store in Elm Grove with an organized selection of toys, books, household goods, shoes, and clothing for men, women, and children. We feature a frequently changing inventory for our shoppers. Our team sorts and presents items neatly for a pleasant shopping experience. We are closed on Wednesdays and Sundays.

Review us
Judie Suleski
2 months ago

Very neat, organized thrift store. Today I hit the jackpot with 50% off everything. And clothing was 70%off. They have a great selection - toys, books, household, shoes, holiday, men's, women's, and children's clothing. The volunteers are friendly. Everything is very organized. The selection is always changing, so it's good to check often.

T Carlson
6 months ago

This used to be one of my favorite thrift stores! The ladies working there are very friendly, but WOW, they have gotten obnoxious with their prices!!!!! With that being said, I will not be returning.

Candi Wildhaber
7 months ago

Cute little shop, very friendly volunteers. I found price reasonable and the day I went, everything was 50% off! They were giving out stuffies with a $10 purchase. I only spent $8 and the still gave me one! A medium size squish melon unicorn colors that my 3 yr old granddaughter is going to LOVE🥰 ALSO- in the cutest little town. I mean ADORABLE!

Daniela Perez
8 months ago

Super clean, decent selection. you get what you pay for here. I thought the reviews were funny talking about all the gossiping old ladies, but they weren’t lying. The moment you walk in they all literately just talking about each other. 5/5 for the juicy old lady gossip 😂😂😂

Cal
a year ago

Prices are laughable. Here are three examples: - A dented, USED Yeti water bottle for $25. - A moderately cool sweater for $25. - An ugly, WORN sweater you could have bought from Kohls for $6 15 years ago. There are so many items in this store you can legitimately buy cheaper for new. What used to be an awesome thrift shop has become the epitome of greed.

Frequently asked

  • What are your hours?

    Local time · GMT-5

    • Mon – Tue9:00 AM – 4:00 PM
    • WednesdayClosed
    • Thu – Fri9:00 AM – 4:00 PM
    • Saturday9:00 AM – 1:00 PM
    • SundayClosed

Is this yours?

Claim it to update photos, contact details and booking links, and reply to enquiries.

Claim this listing