Hefner's Frozen Custard & Jumbo Burgers

Andrea Toms

2 weeks ago

My family and I went here for the first time yesterday. Service was good, but the food was just OK. The burger in my opinion was very bland, it definitely needs more seasoning and could have been cooked longer. My shake also tasted warm, so I wasn’t able to really enjoy it and this even with the first few sips. My fiancée had the fish sandwich and same thing, lacked seasoning. Love supporting local but the food needs more seasoning.

Paul Casanova

3 weeks ago

Basically a nice, typical, Wisconsin custard and burger stand. I ordered a burger with lettuce, tomato and mayo. The burger was like all the rest but with an upgraded brioche bun. They have many specialty burger choices too which seemed to be a cut above the rest. My banana split was delicious too.

Craig Rausch

3 months ago

Great burgers, but staff doesn't seem to pay attention. One of the girls looked right at my order sitting on the counter by the grill and just left it there. There were also two other orders sitting there. All 3 orders had to wait until the other girl finished taking orders.

Travis

11 months ago

Fries are kind of soggy and salty. Custard is good. Burgers and chicken out of dry and overcooked. Definitely need to appreciate the nostalgia. This place has been here forever and that regards it hits all the marks.

Mike Ropicky

a year ago

Hefner’s is a small custard stand located between Cedarburg and Grafton WI. Large “saucer” burgers (prepare to order), chicken and fish sandwiches. Fresh made custards and sundaes. Weekly specials. Daily custard specials (flavors of the days). Small indoor & outdoor sitting area. This establishment has been around a while. Since I was a kid. Was originally an A&W I burger stand. Then became Hefners many years later. This shop is a bit of a copy cat of Kopps Custard stand in terms of the burger size. But more burger varieties to choose from. Certainly a local favorite. A place we have gone to for years.